Paradise Ice Cream - Delightful Flavors in Sebastian, FL

Garbage Can Ice Cream on Peanut Chocolate Waffle Cone

Top categories (Featured Items / Homemade Waffle / Drinks)
Most orders: ₫

Welcome to Paradise Ice Cream! Nestled conveniently at 482 US-1 #4 in Sebastian, FL, this charming ice cream shop is a delightful escape from the everyday hustle. Known for its ooey-gooey goodness, Paradise Ice Cream specializes in a wide range of both traditional and unique flavors that cater to all palates.

Step inside, and you’ll be greeted by the inviting aroma of freshly churned ice cream. The atmosphere is vibrant and friendly—a perfect spot for families and ice cream lovers of all ages. As you peruse the impressive menu, your senses will be tantalized by flavors such as Creamsicle Freeze, an indulgent blend that offers a refreshing taste of summer, and the ever-popular Banana Split, a decadent treat sure to please any sweet tooth.

For those seeking a rich, creamy experience, don’t miss the renowned Pumpkin and Rum Raisin flavors, both of which have received glowing reviews. A customer, Kristie Gonzalez, delighted in the “super tasty” ice creams, highlighting that the rum raisin would have been her grandfather’s favorite—a testament to the nostalgia and satisfaction this shop brings.

Have dietary restrictions? Paradise Ice Cream has you covered with dairy-free soft serve options, such as the refreshing orange Dole Whip and a tempting raspberry sorbet. These offerings ensure no one has to miss out on the joy of ice cream, as Kristin Kelly discovered during her visit.

There are also plenty of fun add-ons to personalize your treat! Choose from dry toppings like mango or kiwi lime for just $0.80, and elevate your dessert with a homemade waffle for an extra touch of heartiness at $0.50.

What sets this shop apart is not just the exceptional quality of ice cream but the incredibly welcoming staff. Shania and Sharon have been praised for their outstanding customer service, creating an atmosphere that feels like a cozy gathering of friends. According to Jorge Bustillos, they provide an experience that leaves you feeling valued and eager to return.

Paradise Ice Cream is more than just a place to enjoy a sweet treat; it’s a local gem where laughter fills the air and delicious flavors swirl. Whether you’re stopping by after a beach day or looking for a fun family outing, be prepared to make memories wrapped in a cone of happiness. With plans to return, many families, like HKelley730's, have made this ice cream shop a cherished part of their vacation experience.

So why wait? Grab your loved ones and dive into a world of flavor at Paradise Ice Cream—where every scoop is a taste of bliss!

Contact Information:
Phone: +1 772-228-8126

Has wheelchair-accessible car park
Has wheelchair-accessible entrance

On-site services available
Offers takeaway
No delivery
No same-day delivery

Good for solo dining

Accepts credit cards
Accepts debit cards
Accepts NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Kristie Gonzalez

08/12/2025

I am so happy we found this place. The ice cream was super tasty. The pumpkin was the best I’ve ever had, as well as their rum raisin (my Poppie would have loved it) the espresso chocolate outstanding, the kids were in heaven with the cookie dough and cookies and cream cones too. Shania and Sharon’s customer service was an 11 out of 10. I highly recommend! We will definitely be back.

HKelley730

25/11/2025

Absolutely spectacular mom and pop ice cream shop. They have spectrums of varieties of unique flavors. I fell in love with the purple scoop. My family of 5 took a trip here for a few days and ate here twice, with plans to come back regularly. The team behind the counter is hilarious, and they seem to genuinely love what they do. Excellent product and service. Clean tables and floors. Plenty of napkins, good serving sizes. Check out the bookstore Nextdoor too!

Kristin Kelly

05/11/2025

I was sooo happy to find somewhere with dairy free soft-serve ice cream. They had orange dole whip & vanilla soft-serve. They also had dairy free raspberry sorbet that looked so good too. They also had so many flavors for regular ice cream. We will definitely be returning here!

Jorge Bustillos

13/10/2025

Our first time and we absolutely loved their ice cream!! Other reviewers were undoubtedly correct. Lots of flavor choices, excellent service and a great atmosphere. We’ll definitely be back!!

Mauricio Montero

15/09/2025

Really good ice cream!! 100% recommended Pretty place also

Chris Crisafulli

03/09/2025

My family and I were trying to get a good beach day in, but the skies opened up. On our way back home, I tried to think of what would be a nice treat to round out our day. I searched maps for Ice cream on the way, and this beautiful place presented itself. It was a great experience from when we first arrived, an extremely friendly atmosphere. They had all of the flavors, we have grown to love, but a fair amount of new ones too. Service was incredible, we are planning to make this a staple for whenever we are over this way. One more thing to add, if you do happen to visit here, don't forget to join their in house rewards program. Next time I'm there I'll grab some photos and add them.

Jean Becker

31/08/2025

Paradise Ice Cream has such a wide variety of flavors to pick from. Their ice cream is as delicious as homemade ice cream. Sharon and Shaniyah were very friendly and accommodating. We will definitely be back.

Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *